Kenny Pickett
Quarterback · Pittsburgh Steelers
Panini Contenders - Supernatural ##SN-5
Year & Era
2022 — Modern Era
Card Type
Rookie Insert Parallel (Green Foil)
Grade
6.0 (EX) estimated
Rarity
Uncommon; the Supernatural green foil is a retail parallel but not as rare as the autograph or low-numbered hobby versions.
Overall Assessment
A visually striking rookie insert featuring a former first-round QB, unfortunately limited in value by noticeable condition flaws and the player's current depth chart status.
Condition Grade
6.0 (EX) estimated
Centering Assessment
Front centering appears slightly heavy toward the left and bottom; back is not visible but likely standard for this insert set.
Surface Condition
Near Mint; the high-gloss surface appears to be free of major scratches, though fingerprints and minor scuffing are common on these black-bordered inserts.
Corner Condition
Fair/Good; significant whitening/damage is visible on the top right corner and bottom right corner, which heavily impacts the numerical grade.
Edge Condition
Good; visible chipping and white wear along the right vertical edge and top edge, likely from being stored outside of a protective sleeve.
Print Quality
Average; the black borders are notch-sensitive and show white paper loss very easily. Foil stamping appears crisp.
Estimated Value
$3.00 - $8.00 USD
Comparison to Known Examples
This copy is in below-average condition compared to Gem Mint pack-fresh examples due to significant edge and corner wear.
Authentication Tips
Check for the holofoil 'RC' logo and Panini's specific high-gloss finish. Counterfeits of standard retail inserts are rare due to low production cost vs profit.
Grading Recommendation
Not recommended; current condition (corners/edges) would result in a low grade, and the card's market value does not justify the grading fee.
Red Flags
No significant signs of alteration, but the card shows clear signs of poor storage and handling (lack of sleeve/toploader).
Provenance Notes
Likely pulled from a 2022 Panini Contenders Retail blaster or hanger box.
Historical Context
Kenny Pickett was the only quarterback selected in the first round of the 2022 NFL Draft, making him a high-profile hobby target during his rookie season in Pittsburgh.
Market Trends
Declining; Pickett’s market has cooled significantly following his trade to the Philadelphia Eagles and transition to a backup role.
Investment Potential
Low; as a backup quarterback on a second team with visible condition issues, this card is primarily a personal collection (PC) item.
Similar Cards
2022 Panini Prizm Kenny Pickett Rookie, 2022 Donruss Optic The Elite Series Rookies.
Display & Preservation
Should be placed immediately in a penny sleeve and a 35pt top loader to prevent further edge chipping.
Interesting Facts
The Supernatural insert set features a mystical, orb-like design and was a new addition to the Contenders lineup in 2022.